Abstract
Purpose:
Post-vasectomy semen analysis (PVSA) is the traditional method of confirming sterility after vasectomy. However, PVSA protocols vary in the end points accepted, and the number and timing of tests. In this systematic review we make evidence based recommendations on the appropriate PVSA protocol.
Materials and Methods:
Databases (MEDLINE, Current Contents, Cochrane Library and EMBASE) were searched up to and including March 2003. Studies were included if they dealt with post-vasectomy testing and contained data on at least 1 of the time or number of ejaculations to azoospermia, pregnancy, repeat vasectomy and histological analysis of vas specimens.
Results:
A total of 56 studies were included in the review. Time to achieve azoospermia was variable, although the median incidence of patients with azoospermia was consistently more than 80% after 3 months and after 20 ejaculations. A small percent of patients (14,845 or 1.4%) demonstrated persistent nonmotile sperm, although some of them eventually achieved azoospermia. The reappearance of nonmotile sperm was reported in 7 studies, occurring up to 22 months after vasectomy.
Conclusions:
The evidence supports a PVSA protocol with 1 test showing azoospermia after 3 months and 20 ejaculations. If the sample is positive, periodic testing can continue until azoospermia is achieved. Patients with persistent nonmotile sperm in low numbers could be given cautious assurance of success. No evidence was located to support histological testing of the excised vas deferens.
References
- 1 Contraceptive Sterilization: Global Issues and Trends. New York: EngenderHealth2002. Google Scholar
- 2 : Safety and effectiveness of vasectomy. Fertil Steril2000; 73: 923. Google Scholar
- 3 : Vasectomy. Andrologia2001; 33: 125. Google Scholar
- 4 Vasectomy: operative procedures and sterility tests not standardized. Fam Plann Perspect1979; 11: 122. Google Scholar
- 5 : Vasectomy: what are community standards?. Urology1986; 27: 328. Crossref, Google Scholar
- 6 : Review of current practice to establish success after vasectomy. Br J Surg2001; 88: 290. Google Scholar
- 7 : Clinical aspects of vasectomies performed in the United States in 1995. Urology1998; 52: 685. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar
- 8 : Post vasectomy analysis: call for a uniform evidence-based protocol. Ann R Coll Surg Engl2001; 83: 177. Google Scholar
- 9 : Vasectomy: a simple postoperative regimen. Med J Aust1977; 1: 814. Google Scholar
- 10 : Earlier testing after vasectomy, based on the absence of motile sperm. Fertil Steril1993; 59: 431. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar
- 11 : Irrigation of the distal vas deferens during vasectomy: does it accelerate the post-vasectomy sperm-free rate?. Int J Androl2001; 24: 241. Google Scholar
- 12 : British Andrology Society guidelines for the assessment of post vasectomy semen samples (2002). J Clin Pathol2002; 55: 812. Google Scholar
- 13 : Semen analysis after vasectomy: when and how many?. BJU Int2000; 86: 479. Google Scholar
- 14 : Persistence or reappearance of nonmotile sperm after vasectomy: does it have clinical consequences?. Fertil Steril1997; 67: 332. Google Scholar
- 15 : Review of current practice to establish success after vasectomy (Br J Surg, 2001; 88: 290–3). Br J Surg2001; 88: 1267. Google Scholar
- 16 : Is the timing of post-vasectomy analysis important?. Br J Urol1998; 82: 461. Google Scholar
- 17 : Recanalization following vasectomy. Urology1974; 3: 211. Crossref, Google Scholar
- 18 : Recanalization rate following methods of vasectomy using interposition of fascial sheath of vas deferens. J Urol1978; 120: 178. Link, Google Scholar
- 19 : Experiences of vasectomy for voluntary sterilisation of males. Scand J Urol Nephrol1973; 7: 123. Google Scholar
- 20 : Vasectomy for voluntary male sterilisation. Scand J Urol Nephrol1975; 9: 174. Google Scholar
- 21 : Follow-up study of outpatient vasectomy. Ugeskr Laeger1979; 141: 1913. Google Scholar
- 22 : Onset of azoospermia after vasectomy. N Z Med J1985; 98: 331. Google Scholar
- 23 : Is the timing of post-vasectomy seminal analysis important?. Br J Urol1998; 81: 458. Google Scholar
- 24 : A review of 357 bilateral vasectomies for male sterilization. Fertil Steril1984; 41: 424. Google Scholar
- 25 : Evaluation of one-hundred open-ended vasectomies. Contraception1986; 33: 529. Google Scholar
- 26 : The lurking sperm. A review of failures in 8879 vasectomies performed by one physician. JAMA1988; 259: 3142. Google Scholar
- 27 A guide to the development, implementation and evaluation of clinical practice guidelines. Australia: ACT, National Health and Medical Research Council1999. Google Scholar
- 28 : General and anomalous sperm disappearance characteristics found in a large vasectomy series. Fertil Steril1989; 51: 859. Google Scholar
- 29 : Post-vasectomy semen in 313 males. Statistical analysis, medical aspects, legal implications. Arch Esp Urol1993; 46: 29. Google Scholar
- 30 : The high rate of noncompliance for post-vasectomy semen examination: medical and legal considerations. J Urol1990; 144: 284. Link, Google Scholar
- 31 : Persistent spermatozoa after vasectomy: a survey of British urologists. Br J Urol1995; 76: 376. Google Scholar
- 32 : The evolution of the Marie Stopes electrocautery no-scalpel vasectomy procedure. J Fam Plann Reprod Health Care2002; 28: 137. Google Scholar
- 33 : Post-vasectomy semen analysis: unnecessary delay or belt and braces?. Br J Fam Plann1997; 23: 77. Google Scholar
- 34 : Results of a pilot study of the time to azoospermia after vasectomy in Mexico City. Contraception1997; 56: 215. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar
- 35 : Vasectomy by electrocautery: outcomes in a series of 2,500 patients. J Fam Pract1985; 21: 35. Google Scholar
- 36 : Non-motile sperms persisting after vasectomy: do they matter?. Br Med J1979; 1: 1019. Google Scholar
- 37 : Late failure of vasectomy after two documented analyses showing azoospermic semen. Br Med J1984; 289: 77. Google Scholar
- 38 : The long-term outcome following “special clearance” after vasectomy. Br J Urol1990; 66: 211. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar
- 39 : How reliable is a vasectomy? Long-term follow-up of vasectomised men. Lancet2000; 356: 43. Google Scholar
- 40 : Temporary reappearance of sperm 12 months after vasectomy clearance. Br J Urol1995; 76: 371. Google Scholar
- 41 : Disappearance rate of spermatozoa from the ejaculate following vasectomy. Fertil Steril1969; 20: 163. Crossref, Google Scholar
- 42 : A male sterilization clinic. Br Med J1970; 4: 295. Google Scholar
- 43 : Vasectomy: a review of 3200 operations. Can Med Assoc J1971; 105: 1065. Google Scholar
- 44 : Patient noncompliance after vasectomy. Fertil Steril1997; 68: 552. Google Scholar
- 45 : Variability of sperm disappearance from the ejaculate after vasectomy. J Urol1972; 107: 815. Link, Google Scholar
- 46 : Transient reappearance of sperm after vasectomy. JAMA1972; 219: 1753. Google Scholar
- 47 : A follow up study of 200 men after vasectomy. Health Bull1986; 44: 137. Google Scholar
- 48 : Spontaneous recanalisation of the divided vas deferens. Br J Urol1969; 41: 340. Google Scholar
- 49 : Follow-up study of 247 vasectomies. Helv Chir Acta1984; 51: 441. Google Scholar
- 50 : Vasectomy: problems of follow up. Proc R Soc Med1973; 66: 52. Google Scholar
- 51 : Vasectomy in Guatemala: a follow-up study of five hundred acceptors. Soc Biol1981; 28: 253. Google Scholar
- 52 : Sperm studies following sterilization by vasectomy. How often and how long after the intervention. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd1975; 119: 1351. Google Scholar
- 53 : Fatherhood without apparent spermatozoa after vasectomy. Lancet1994; 344: 30. Google Scholar
- 54 : An analysis of 870 bilateral vasectomies. J Med Assoc Thai1989; 72: 230. Google Scholar
- 55 One thousand vasectomies. Br Med J1973; 4: 216. Google Scholar
- 56 : Disappearance of spermatozoa from ejaculate after vasectomy. Br Med J1979; 1: 87. Google Scholar
- 57 : Experience with sperm counts following vasectomy. Br J Urol1991; 68: 230. Google Scholar
- 58 : Sperm analysis following vasectomy: when to perform a revasectomy?. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd1985; 129: 1579. Google Scholar
- 59 : Spontaneous recanalization of the vas deferens. Int Surg1977; 62: 557. Google Scholar
- 60 : Recanalization of the vas following vasectomy. Br J Urol1997; 79: 484. Google Scholar
- 61 : Postvasectomy residual sperm pregnancy. Fertil Steril1980; 33: 668. Google Scholar
- 62 : Fatherhood with no apparent spermatozoa. BJU Int2000; 86: 407. Google Scholar
- 63 : Sperm centrifugation in azoospermia?. Andrologia1984; 16: 381. Google Scholar
- 64 : Paternity by a seemingly infertile vasectomised man. BMJ1993; 307: 299. Google Scholar
- 65 : Monitoring for azoospermia following vasectomy: time course and patient compliance. Fertil Steril2001; 76: S187. Google Scholar
- 66 Letter: one thousand vasectomies. Br Med J1973; 4: 418. Google Scholar
- 67 : Biostatistical Analysis. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall International1984. Google Scholar
- 68 Griffin T., Tooher R., Nowakowski K., Lloyd M., Maddern G., Post-vasectomy testing to confirm sterility: a systematic review. Adelaide, South Australia: ASERNIP-S, Report No. 3, 2003 Google Scholar
- 69 : Delayed spontaneous recanalization of the vas deferens. Br J Surg1984; 71: 532. Google Scholar
- 70 : Factors determining the rate of disappearance of sperm from the ejaculate after vasectomy. Br J Surg1976; 63: 477. Google Scholar
- 71 : Disappearance of spermatozoa from semen after vasectomy. J Popul Res1976; 3: 61. Google Scholar
- 72 : Effectiveness and complications associated with 2 vasectomy occlusion techniques. J Urol2002; 168: 2495. Link, Google Scholar
From the Australian Safety and Efficacy Register of New Interventional Procedures-Surgical, Royal Australasian College of Surgeons (TG, RT, GM), Adelaide and Department of Surgery, University of Adelaide, Queen Elizabeth Hospital (KN, ML, GM), Woodville, South Australia, Australia
© 2005 by American Urological Association, Inc.
