A 7-YEAR EXPERIENCE OF GENETIC MALES WITH SEVERE PHALLIC INADEQUACY ASSIGNED FEMALE
Abstract
Purpose:
We examine the hypotheses underlying the clinical decision to assign female gender at birth in male neonates with severe phallic inadequacy.
Materials and Methods:
A total of 18 genetic males with severe phallic inadequacy were assessed longitudinally for physical, social, psychological and sexual identity development. Diagnoses included cloacal (11) and classic (1) exstrophy, partial androgen resistance (3), mixed gonadal dysgenesis (2) and penile agenesis (1). Neonatal sex assignment was female in 15 and male in 3 patients.
Results:
All patients demonstrated marked male typical behaviors and interests. Of the 15 female assigned patients 1 died, 1 refused to declare sexual identity or orientation, 1 converted to male before initial evaluation, 1 was reassigned male by the parents and 5 others declared male sexual identity. Thus, of 17 living patients 10 live as males and 6 as females. Of patients 17 years or older only those living as male lived independently. The 4 oldest patients living as male but only 1 patient living as female would discuss sexual orientation—all 5 declared orientation toward females, and 3 of these 4 males had girlfriends or were married. The sexually undeclared patient lived in a residential treatment center because of major behavioral difficulties since age 15. Only patients living as male had dated.
Conclusions:
This longitudinal study implies that males with severe phallic inadequacy reared male and those reared female but converting to male can have functional psychosocial developmental trajectories. Those reared female have a realistic likelihood of recognizing male sexual identity and converting to male. Those not converting to male appear to have less successful psychosocial developmental trajectories.
References
- 1 : Cloacal exstrophy: experience with 20 cases. J Pediatr Surg1993; 28: 1360. Google Scholar
- 2 : Principles of management of exstrophy of the cloaca. Am J Surg1970; 119: 95. Google Scholar
- 3 :
Psychosexual differentiation as a function of androgenic stimulation . In: Perspectives in Reproduction and Sexual Behavior. Edited by . Bloomington: Indiana University Press1968: 33. Google Scholar - 4 : Man & Woman, Boy & Girl: The Differentiation and Dimorphism of Gender Identity From Conception to Maturity. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press1972: 1. 118–123, 152–154, 176–179. Google Scholar
- 5 : Optimal management of cloacal exstrophy. J Pediatr Surg1983; 18: 365. Google Scholar
- 6 : Phallic reconstruction in cloacal exstrophy. J Urol1989; 142: 563. Link, Google Scholar
- 7 :
Anatomy of cloacal exstrophy, the surgical implications . In: The Exstrophy-Epispadias Complex, Research Concepts and Clinical Applications. Edited by . New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum1999: 199. Google Scholar - 8 : Androgens and the evolution of male-gender identity among male pseudohermaphrodites with 5alpha-reductase deficiency. N Engl J Med1979; 300: 1233. Google Scholar
- 9 : Small penis and the male sexual role. J Urol1989; 142: 569. Link, Google Scholar
- 10 : Congenital hypogonadotropic hypogonadism and micropenis: effect of testosterone treatment on adult penile size why sex reversal is not indicated. J Pediatr1999; 134: 579. Google Scholar
- 11 : Effects of early androgens on sex-typed activities and interests in adolescents with congenital adrenal hyperplasia. Horm Behav1999; 35: 102. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar
- 12 : Sex reassignment at birth. Long-term review and clinical implications. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med1997; 151: 298. Google Scholar
- 13 : Pediatric management of ambiguous and traumatized genitalia. J Urol1999; 162: 1021. Link, Google Scholar
- 14 : A framework for the ethically justified clinical management of intersex conditions. Adv Exp Med Biol2002; 511: 149. Google Scholar
- 15 : Discordant sexual identity in some genetic males with cloacal exstrophy assigned to female sex at birth. N Engl J Med2004; 350: 333. Google Scholar
- 16 : The ultimate challenge of cloacal exstrophy. J Urol2002; 167: 300. Link, Google Scholar
From the Departments of Urology and Psychiatry, University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
