Abstract
Purpose:
In the mid 1800s Dr. J. Marion Sims reported the successful repair of vesicovaginal fistulas with a technique he developed by performing multiple operations on female slaves. A venerated physician in his time, the legacy of Dr. Sims is controversial and represents a significant chapter in the mistreatment of African-Americans by the medical establishment. This review compares the modern debate surrounding his legacy with the presentation of his operation in widely consulted urological texts and journals.
Materials and Methods:
A literature review was performed of medical, sociological and periodical sources (1851 to the present) regarding J. Marion Sims and vesicovaginal fistula repair.
Results:
During the last several decades, while the controversy around Dr. Sims' surgical development has produced a steady stream of articles in the historical and popular literature, relatively little mention is found in standard urology textbooks or journals. With increased public attention, some have debated the removal or modification of public tributes to Dr. Sims. This move has been countered by arguments against the validity of judging a 19th century physician by modern standards.
Conclusions:
While historians, ethicists and the popular press have debated Dr. Sims' legacy, medical sources have continued to portray him unquestionably as a great figure in medical history. This division keeps the medical profession uninformed and detached from the public debate on his legacy and, thus, the larger issues of ethical treatment of surgical patients.
References
- 1 A Famous Surgeon Dead: The important life work of Dr. J. Marion Sims. : The New York TimesNovember 14, 1883. Google Scholar
- 2 : Medical Apartheid: The Dark History of Medical Experimentation on Black Americans From Colonial Times to the Present. New York: Doubleday2006. Google Scholar
- 3 : The Historical Marker Database. 2009. Birthplace of Dr. James Marion Sims Marker http://www.hmdb.org/marker.asp?marker=23891. Accessed October 31, 2009. Google Scholar
- 4 : The Story of My Life. New York: Appleton and Company1894. Google Scholar
- 5 : Woman's Surgeon: The Life Story of J. Marion Sims. New York: Macmillan1950. Google Scholar
- 6 : The father of gynecology (James Marion Sims). Ala J Med Sci1972; 9: 33. Google Scholar
- 7 : Dr. J. Marion Sims. J Med Assoc State Ala1976; 45: 19. Google Scholar
- 8 : J.Marion Sims, M.D.–gynecologic surgeon. N Y State J Med1963; 63: 3533. Google Scholar
- 9 : J.Marion Sims (1813–1883) and the vesicovaginal fistula. J S C Med Assoc1971; 67: 271. Google Scholar
- 10 : The medical ethics of the ‘father of gynaecology’, Dr J Marion Sims. J Med Ethics1993; 19: 28. Google Scholar
- 11 : The Horrors of the Half-Known Life: Male Attitudes Toward Women and Sexuality in Nineteeth-Century America. New York: Routledge1974. Google Scholar
- 12 : Sexual Surgery and the Origins of Gynecology: J. Marion Sims, His Hospital, and His Patients. New York: Garland Publishing1989. Google Scholar
- 13 : The medical ethics of Dr J Marion Sims: a fresh look at the historical record. J Med Ethics2006; 32: 346. Google Scholar
- 14 : An American Health Dilemma: A Medical History of African Americans and the Problem of Race. New York: Routledge2000. Google Scholar
- 15 : The Way We Live Now: Stand-Up Women. : The New York TimesOctober 5, 2003. Google Scholar
- 16 : Scholars Argue Over Legacy of Surgeon Who Was Lionized, Then Vilified. : The New York TimesOctober 28, 2003. Google Scholar
- 17 : On the treatment of vesico-vaginal fistula. 1852. Int Urogynecol J Pelvic Floor Dysfunct1998; 9: 236. Google Scholar
- 18 : The epochs and ethics of incontinence surgery: is the direction forward or backwards?. Int Urogynecol J Pelvic Floor Dysfunct2002; 13: 1. Google Scholar
Division of Urology, Department of Surgery, Albany Medical College, Albany, New York
